If the insurance adjuster says your injury was from an old accident, you are not required to agree with that assessment and you can push back. It’s one of the most common tactics used to shrink or deny a payout, and it doesn’t automatically mean your claim is over. Adjusters are trained to look for any reason to point to something other than the current crash.
Even if you had a prior injury, Texas law still allows you to recover for a new accident that made it worse. The real issue isn’t whether you had a past injury. It’s whether this crash caused new harm or aggravated something that already existed.
At AK Law Firm, we see this tactic often, and we know how to counter it. A Texas car accident lawyer on our team can pull together the medical evidence needed to show exactly what this accident did to your body, regardless of your medical history.
This tactic works because it sounds reasonable on the surface. Nobody’s body is a blank slate, and most adults have some old ache or past injury somewhere. Adjusters count on that being enough to create doubt, even when the timeline and symptoms clearly point to the new crash.
Recognizing this as a tactic, rather than a legitimate roadblock, is the first step in pushing back effectively.
For a free legal consultation, call (866) 693-7098
Texas Law on Aggravated and Pre-Existing Injuries
Texas law is clear on this point: if an accident makes an existing injury worse, you’re entitled to compensation for that aggravation. You don’t have to prove you were in perfect health beforehand. You only have to show that the crash caused new damage or made an old problem measurably worse.
This concept is sometimes called the “eggshell skull” rule, and Texas courts have long recognized it. Under this principle, an at-fault driver is responsible for the actual harm they cause, even if you were more vulnerable to injury than an average person. A prior condition doesn’t reduce the responsibility of the driver who hit you.
That said, the burden is on you to draw a clear line between your prior condition and the new injury or aggravation. That’s where solid medical evidence becomes essential.
Building Medical Evidence to Counter This Argument
The strongest way to counter an adjuster’s “old injury” argument is with a clear medical timeline. If you had a past injury that had healed or stabilized before this accident, records showing that recovery are valuable. A doctor’s note saying you were symptom-free, or had returned to normal activity, can directly contradict the adjuster’s story.
If you had an ongoing condition that got worse after the crash, your medical provider can document that change too. Comparing imaging, treatment notes, or symptom reports from before and after the accident often shows a clear difference. This kind of before-and-after comparison is one of the most persuasive tools in these disputes.
It also helps to be consistent and upfront with your own doctors about your medical history. Trying to hide a prior injury can backfire and damage your credibility, while being honest about it and letting the medical evidence speak for itself puts you in a much stronger position.
Click to contact our personal injury lawyers today
What to Do When an Adjuster Won’t Budge
Sometimes, even with solid medical evidence, an adjuster keeps insisting your injury isn’t new. If that happens, don’t get pulled into arguing the point yourself over the phone. Put your response in writing, backed by your doctor’s records, and let the paper trail do the talking.
It also helps to request the specific reasoning behind their position. Ask the adjuster to explain, in writing, exactly why they believe the injury predates this accident. Vague statements are much easier to challenge than specific claims, and forcing them to be specific often reveals how weak their argument really is.
If the adjuster still won’t move, that’s usually a sign the conversation needs to shift from you to your lawyer. At that point, continued back-and-forth rarely helps and may only give the insurer more material to use against you.
Complete a Free Case Evaluation form now
Get Help From Our Car Accident Lawyers
An old injury shouldn’t be used as an excuse to write off what happened to you in this accident. Your body’s history doesn’t cancel out the driver’s responsibility for making things worse, and you shouldn’t have to fight that battle with a stack of medical records alone.
Our team at AK Law Firm has gone up against this exact argument more times than we can count, and we know how to build a timeline that makes the truth hard to ignore. We’ll dig into your medical history, connect it to what happened in this crash, and make sure the insurance company hears from someone who won’t be talked out of a fair result.
If an adjuster is trying to blame an old injury for your current pain, let’s take a look at your case together. The consultation costs you nothing, and you won’t owe us a fee unless we recover for you.
Call or text (866) 693-7098 or complete a Free Case Evaluation form